Sign Up | Advertise | Sales System

In partnership with

🎃 Think farmers choose what pumpkins to grow based on soil and tradition? Three companies decided your jack-o'-lantern's genetics before that farm even existed. Welcome to agricultural monopoly, seed edition.

Read time: 3 minutes | 806 words

STORY 

🎃 3 Companies Control Your Jack-O-Lantern

You think you're choosing that perfect pumpkin at the patch. You're not.

Decades before that orange globe hit the field, three companies decided its shape, size, and color. They own the seeds. They own the genetics. They own October.

🧬 The Seed Oligopoly: 90% of Your Halloween

Three names dominate the pumpkin seed industry:

• Seminis (owned by Bayer/Monsanto since 2005)

• Harris Seeds (operating since 1879)

• Johnny's Selected Seeds (founded 1973)

Together, they control roughly 90% of commercial pumpkin seed genetics in North America. That "heirloom" Connecticut Field pumpkin your local farm grows? Probably came from their vault.

Here's what nobody talks about: Developing a stable pumpkin variety takes 8-12 years of selective breeding. These companies patented the most popular cultivars decades ago—locking farmers into buying seeds year after year.

🌱 The Lock-In: Plant Variety Protection Certificates

The industry runs on PVP certificates—legal monopolies lasting 20-25 years on specific seed varieties. Seminis alone holds patents on varieties like 'Magic Lantern' and 'Gladiator.' Harris Seeds controls 'Bumpkin' and 'Amish Pie.'

Want to save seeds from this year's crop to plant next year? Check the bag. Most commercial varieties are F1 hybrids—they don't breed true. The second generation produces wildly inconsistent pumpkins.

The result? Farmers can't save seeds. They must buy new ones every spring.

🚜 The Squeeze: "We Recommend Our Genetics"

Small seed companies exist, but they're playing a different game. When a farm wants to scale—supplying grocery chains or running a commercial patch—they need consistency. Uniformity. Disease resistance.

That's where the Big Three come in. Their seeds produce pumpkins that:

• Ripen simultaneously for single-harvest efficiency

• Stack without bruising during transport

• Have thick handles that don't snap off

Regional seed companies can't compete with decades of R&D. One agricultural extension agent put it bluntly: "If you're growing more than 5 acres, you're buying from Seminis or Harris."

🎃 The Results: Every Patch, Same Pumpkin

Visit ten "different" pumpkin patches across three states. You'll see the same varieties: Howden, Gladiator, Magic Lantern, Prize Winner.

The genetic diversity of commercial pumpkins has narrowed by an estimated 75% since 1980. Heirloom varieties still exist—but mostly in home gardens, not the fields feeding Spirit Halloween's doorstep displays.

The brilliance? These companies don't sell pumpkins. They sell the right to grow pumpkins—and they've engineered a crop that makes farmers come back every single season.

🔮 The Long Game: Who Owns the Genome?

You're not buying a pumpkin. You're buying the end result of intellectual property developed before you were born.

And when three companies own 90% of the starting material, they don't just control this Halloween—they control the next twenty.

Related: Here’s a ridiculously interesting episode of Chef’s Life about seeds from Sean Brock.

TOGETHER WITH ROKU

Find your customers on Roku this Black Friday

As with any digital ad campaign, the important thing is to reach streaming audiences who will convert. To that end, Roku’s self-service Ads Manager stands ready with powerful segmentation and targeting options. After all, you know your customers, and we know our streaming audience.

Worried it’s too late to spin up new Black Friday creative? With Roku Ads Manager, you can easily import and augment existing creative assets from your social channels. We also have AI-assisted upscaling, so every ad is primed for CTV.

Once you’ve done this, then you can easily set up A/B tests to flight different creative variants and Black Friday offers. If you’re a Shopify brand, you can even run shoppable ads directly on-screen so viewers can purchase with just a click of their Roku remote.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

INSIGHT + ACTION

5 Lessons from the Pumpkin Cartel

1. Control the Input, Not the Output. Seminis, Harris, and Johnny's don't grow pumpkins—they own the genetics farmers must start with. The crop is commoditized; the seed is the chokepoint.

• Action: Identify the critical input your industry depends on and acquire it. Raw materials, patents, or platform access—whoever controls what everyone needs first wins without competing downstream.

2. Engineer Dependency by Design. F1 hybrid seeds don't breed true. Second-generation plants are worthless. Farmers physically cannot save seeds—they must return every spring.

• Action: Build products that require ongoing repurchase or subscriptions. Consumables beat durables. Compatibility locks beat features. Make switching costs unbearable.

3. Compete on Timescales Your Rivals Can't Match. Developing a stable pumpkin variety takes 8-12 years. Small seed companies can't afford that R&D cycle. By the time they catch up, the Big Three have moved two generations ahead.

• Action: Invest in barriers that take years to replicate—proprietary data, regulatory approvals, breeding programs. If your advantage takes a decade to build, competitors won't even try.

4. Let Operational Requirements Eliminate Alternatives. Regional heirloom seeds still exist. But commercial farms need simultaneous ripening, stackability, disease resistance. Only industrial genetics deliver that.

• Action: Don't outlaw competitors—make their offerings operationally unworkable. Set industry standards that only you can meet at scale. Let "practical requirements" do the exclusion.

5. Narrow Diversity, Maximize Predictability. Genetic diversity dropped 75% since 1980. That's not a bug—it's the business model. Fewer varieties mean farmers buy proven winners, reducing risk for everyone (except consumers).

• Action: Consolidate your product line around bestsellers. Discontinue variations. Standardization increases margins and makes your category legible to mass buyers. Variety is expensive; monoculture scales.

These companies proved you can privatize the biological foundation of a crop—turning seed saving, a practice as old as agriculture, into intellectual property theft. They didn't ban competition; they made independence genetically impossible.

TOGETHER WITH BELAY

Your time is too expensive to waste.

Most leaders lose 15 hours a week to the wrong tasks. The Delegation Guide and Worksheet helps you take them back. BELAY makes it possible with remote staffing solutions — U.S.-based, flexible, and personally matched to fit your business.

Download BELAY’s Free Guide!

MEME